Our Vision

To rephrase Rumi, the great Persian poet: 

Somewhere between (and beyond) Intellectual, Property, and Rights lies a space where ideas (e)merge, creativity cascades, epistemes evaporate, discourses dissolve, and structures melt. We seek to meet you there—beyond the binaries of theory and practice."

Notes from an IP theory enthusiast—and a pair of unrepentant IP musers. This platform has a purpose. Through our law school journeys, we’ve come to appreciate the richness of theoretical reading and academic work, but we’ve also been reminded—often—that a Great Divide exists between the law we study and how law is actually practised. The echoes of this divide resonate through the hallowed halls of courtrooms, law classrooms, bureaucratic offices, and beyond. And that’s where the roots of this blog were laid.

The purpose here is straightforward: to think aloud, ideate, and pen ideas that pique or even peeve our interests, while challenging—and hopefully bridging—that great divide between theory and practice. Put differently, this blog aims to dissect academia and test its essence and relevance in real-world practice. This is a reader’s perspective, for our readers. We want to share our understanding of the material discussed—and nothing beyond it. Don’t trust us too much (we’re students, after all, learning by writing and thinking together), but do read, respond, and join the conversation.

Intellectual Property (IP)— the law that has of late become the fulcrum of knowledge governance and information regulation — has intuitively drawn both of us in. We, as one could call it, are IP aficionados (not to mean that we are pro-Intellectual Property – we are conflicted on that). We LOVE reading, theorising, philosophising about IP, exploring diverse ideas connected to how they shape policies around information regulation. Beyond casual reading, we’ve been fortunate enough to dive into the academic works of renowned and emerging IP scholars worldwide, gaining exposure to a broad spectrum of thoughts and debates on the very purpose of IP itself. (A big thanks to our friends, mentors, employers, supervisors, and colleagues who have constantly nudged our thinking in these directions.) Through this platform, we aim to engage our readers (hopefully students, academics, practitioners, judges, and other interested pals) in these academic readings and thoughts, and rethink the intuitive dialogue that surrounds the areas of IP.

This blog brings you the perspectives of various legal theorists and philosophers, exploring how their ideas can be used, questioned, and deployed in the study of IP. For example, we delve into Kant’s philosophy of “autonomy” concerning copyright, Foucault’s concepts of discourse and episteme, Devy’s notion of cultural amnesia, Spivak’s idea of subaltern speech, and Shiv Visvanathan’s concept of cognitive justice, among others. As we read more, we will share more on such thinkers and contextualise their relevance in today’s IP debates.

Most importantly, while many existing blogs focus on IP issues in the EU and US—which frequently dominate comparative studies—we want to target Indian IP law, especially Indian copyright law: its legislative framework, jurisprudence, and court interpretations. However, if time and energy permit, we plan to take a closer look at the IP landscape across South Asia as well. Additionally, we also aim to present insights from various other projects that we are working on together, as well as individually, for anyone interested in contributing to the conversation.

WHAT WE DO NOT DO:

On this platform, while we generally steer clear of discussing case laws or the latest developments in a direct manner, if temptation strikes, we might offer some theoretical reflections or invite a friend to share their take. For thorough commentary and analysis on case laws and related jurisprudence, check IPRMENT Law and SpicyIP, where we regularly contribute and absolutely love it! We must also acknowledge that it was through these blogs that our primary thinking and passion for IP law first took root, and we remain deeply grateful for their guidance and support.

Welcome to our immersive world of IP Theory and Academia. I hope we have a journey worth remembering!

WHO ARE WE:

Akshat Agrawal

PhD Candidate (University of Cambridge)
LLM (IP Law and Technology), Berkeley Law;
BA.LLB (Hons) Jindal Global Law School, India

I read law and its intersection with culture and knowledge production, dissemination and consumption. I have been an Indian Classical Vocalist and a music lover for as long as I can remember. I hope to get all the perspectives that I have gained, by virtue of being an artist myself, on the table here. I am currently a PhD student at University of Cambridge under the supervision of Prof. Lionel Bently. Profs. Talha Syed and Oren Bracha are my lifetime mentors.

Email me: 97akshatag@gmail.com

LinkedIn: Here
SSRN: https://papers.ssrn.com/sol3/cf_dev/AbsByAuth.cfm?per_id=4453958

Lokesh Vyas

PhD Candidate, SciencesPO, Paris. LLM, American University Washington School of Law (Arcadia Fellow, 2021 and Arodhum Scholar); B.Com LLB (Hons) – Nirma University, India.


I’m a PhD student at SciencesPo, Paris, working with Professors Séverine Dusollier and Alain Pottage. My research looks at the history of the “balance” idea in international copyright law, exploring how legal thinking around copyright has evolved since the late 19th century. More broadly, I’m interested in how knowledge and information are governed, and I enjoy exploring them through a historical perspective.


Besides my research, I regularly write for Indian IP blogs like SpicyIP and IPRMENTLAW. I also enjoy entering essay competitions and have been fortunate to win a few, including the first Shamnad Basheer Essay Competition in 2020 and the ATRIP Annual Essay Competition in 2024.

I am here: lokeshvyas025@hotmail.com

LinkedIn: Here

SSRN Page: Here

Disclaimer:

While we indicated this above, we are students of IP policy, not experts. None of our views here is final or conclusive. Our main goal is to clarify our own thinking by musing aloud on ideas close to our hearts—and inviting you, our readers, to join us in that process. By sharing these reflections, we hope to unpack and challenge our intuitive thoughts, moving from a state of confusion toward greater clarity, if not certainty. While we welcome serious engagement with our ideas, please understand that these are not definitive statements or legal advice. If you require formal opinions or counsel, do reach out to us separately. Here, you find our thoughts as they stand today—ever evolving as we encounter new perspectives and deepen our understanding.

Needless to say, everything said or done on this platform is entirely in our personal capacity, and we are solely and individually responsible for this. This does not in any way, directly or incidentally, concern our employers/employment.